Open Peer Review System

Propose Program Committee Members By Listing Their Emails:

Human Resource Management

Propose Seniors By Listing Their Emails:

Name / Email

Submitter

{{tname.substring(0, 2)}}

Reviewer

{{tname.substring(0, 2)}}

Senior

{{tname.substring(0, 2)}}

Chair

{{tname.substring(0, 2)}}

{{x.fn}}, {{x.gn}} <{{x.e}}>

{{x.S[tid].C}}

Your Public Answer To Review

Answering Review: #{{crt_submission_data.r_ID}} for #{{crt_submission_data.i}} "{{reviewed_submission_title}}"

A nonzero integer, specifying the utility in dollars for this review. Review Utility for Society*: $

Title*:

Body:
Reviewers can use LaTex commands in the body of the answer. An additional set of tags is the mathematical sub/superscripts exemplified in: $x__{y__}^^{z^^}$.
Statements that are specified between <_> can be separately deleted after the answer to reviews are received.

Approximate Preview of Answer To Review (final version will be compiled with LaTex):

{{answer_given_name}} {{answer_family_name}}

{{answer_institution}}

{{answer_email}}

Estimated Utility for Society of
Review "{{reviewed_reviewing_title}}":
${{utility_review}}

Preview of Review (current version):

{{reviewer_given_name}} {{reviewer_family_name}}

{{reviewer_institution}}

{{reviewer_email}}

Estimated Utility of
"{{reviewed_submission_title}}":
Utility to society: ${{reviewed_submission_utility}}
Utility to community: ${{reviewed_submission_utility_community}}

Thanks: {{reviewed_reviewing_coreviewers}}

Approximate Preview of Current Rebuttal To Review (final version will be compiled with LaTex):

{{answer_given_name}} {{answer_family_name}}

{{answer_institution}}

{{answer_email}}

Estimated Utility for Society of
Review "{{reviewed_reviewing_title}}":
${{utility_review}}

Title*:

Authors:

	Surname:	Name:	Email:	Institution:	Contact:

Abstract*:

Keywords*:

My Submissions:

Submissions:

Title

Track

Submitter

P{{x.E}}

{{x.f}}, {{x.g}} {{x.I}}

Do you really want to delete this submission?
delete

FAQ: You are not supposed to assign grades/points in these peer-reviews, or in their rebuttals. The acceptance decision is based on the conference rules. You assign integer values (in dollars) for the usefulness of the provided information/work. Your contribution is to analyze and criticize the merits of the documents assigned to you. You need to check how the documents assigned to you comply with the scientific/engineering method and to the requirements in the call for papers, and to describe all conflicts and merits that you find. Reviewers do not take/give you points. So no need to argue about points, but money. Argue about the correctness of their criticism from an objective scientific/engineering point of view.

Your Public Review

Reviewing: #{{reviewed_submission_ID}} {{reviewed_submission_title}}

Co-Reviewers:

A nonzero integer, specifying the utility in dollars for this report. Submission Utility for Society*: $
A nonzero integer, specifying the utility in dollars for this report. Submission Utility for This Community*: $

Title*:

Body:
Reviewers can use LaTex commands in the body of the review. An additional set of tags is the mathematical sub/superscripts exemplified in: $x__{y__}^^{z^^}$.
Statements that are specified between <_> can be separately deleted after the answer to reviews are received.

Approximate Preview of Review (final version is compiled with LaTex):

{{given_name}} {{family_name}}

{{institution}}

{{email}}

Estimated Utility of
"{{reviewed_submission_title}}":
Utility to society: ${{submission_utility}}
Utility to community: ${{submission_utility_community}}

Thanks: {{reviewing_coreviewers}}

Approximate Preview of Answer To Review (final version is compiled with LaTex):

{{given_name}} {{family_name}}

{{institution}}

{{email}}

Estimated Utility to Society of
Review "{{reviewed_reviewing_title}}":
${{utility_review}}

All Submissions:

		Title	Submitter	Keywords
{{$index + 1}}	P{{x.E}}	{{x.t.substr(0,200)}}{{x.a}}	{{x.f}}, {{x.g}} {{x.I}}	{{x.k.substr(0,100)}}

Login/Email*:
Password*:
Given Name*:
Family Name:
Title:
Contact Email*:
URL:
Institution*:
Department:
Position:
Phone:

{{event_name}}

Human Resource Management

Your Public Answer To Review

{{answer_title}}

{{reviewed_reviewing_title}}

{{answer_title}}

My Submissions:

Submissions:

Your Public Review

{{reviewing_title}}

{{answer_title}}

All Submissions: